Love Island USA's Kaylor Feels 'Bad for That Kaylor' After Watching Clip of Her Crying Over Aaron: 'Leave That Man' (Exclusive)

Mar. 15, 2025

The cast ofLove Island USAis taking a look back at some of their most memorable onscreen moments — andKaylor Martinis starting things off with a bang.

Kaylor,Nicole Jacky,Liv Walker,JaNa Craig, Kenny Rodriguez,Rob RauschandKordell Beckhamjoined PEOPLE to share some behind-the-scenes secrets of dramatic scenes from season 6, and one of Kaylor and Aaron Evans' (many) blow-up fights overhis behavior in Casa Amor with Danielawas among the scenes they reacted to.

While watching it play, Liv says of her BFF, “She’s so pretty when she cries.”

Nicole, 26, then asks Kaylor if she has always been such a crier. “Like, before the show, would you cry that much?”

“So I do cry – I’m the type, if I see a sad, soppy commercial, I’m crying,” Kaylor admits.

‘Love Island USA’ stars Nicole Jacky and Kaylor Martin.

Liv, 22, then comes in with another compliment for Kaylor. “This is an off-topic thing but her eyes go so blue when she cries and it is stunning,” she says.

Nicole makes a similar remark. “I told you, I think your crying is beautiful. You know I do,” she tells Kaylor, who replies, “I’m the ugliest crier, Nicole.”

“No, but it’s beautiful that you can express your emotions,” Nicole adds.

Kordell then steps in with an impression of Kaylor’s often-repeated phrase, “F—, Aaron,” which he then asks Rob to rate. Rob, 25, gives it an 8 out of 10, calling it “accurate.”

“I’ll take it,” Kordell says. “Constructive criticism, I’ll work on that.”

JaNa and Kenny take things more seriously, as JaNa says of the fight, “She’s literally in pain right now and Aaron can’t comprehend that, and it’s frustrating.”

“Aaron put her through war,” Kenny, 24, adds. “She went through everything … And every time, it seems like he’s just smooth with his words.”

Kaylor Martin, Aaron Evans on ‘Love Island USA’ season 6.Ben Symons/Peacock

Ben Symons/Peacock

After watching the heated exchange back, Nicole tells Kaylor what she really thinks about Aaron, prefacing with an “I’m sorry.”

“He makes my blood boil. The way he … I don’t think he ever listened to Kaylor or understood the situation he put her in. He was playing the victim and you need to understand what you put your girl through.”

Liv similarly stood up for Kaylor at Aaron’s expense, calling her “my best friend in the villa.”

“I think he doesn’t deserve her. I don’t. I get everyone makes mistakes, I get everyone f—s up. We’re all human, I get that,” Liv continues. “But when you lie to someone’s face over and over and over again and you take their beautiful personality — of seeing the best in people and putting others before themselves — for granted, then I think, off with the wind.”

(L-R) Olivia ‘Liv’ Walker, Kaylor Martin and Rob Rausch.

Kaylor has since confirmed that she and Aaron are “not together,“and during the season 6 reunion, she called theTraitorsalum “disgusting” when he revealed another previously unknown tidbit about his time in Casa Amor: he “put [his] hands down Daniela’s pants.”

“I’m tired of the f—ing excuses. Take accountability and be a man,“Kaylor told him.

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Love Island USAseason 6 can be streamed in full on Peacock.

source: people.com